Independent Spirits: Faith Hubley/John Hubley

Directed by Sybil DelGaudio, Produced by Patty Wineapple
Independent Spirits website at PBS.org

Independent Spirits: Faith Hubley/John Hubley is a one-hour documentary about art, commerce and the spirit of independent filmmmaking. Set within the context of six decades of American cultural history, the film looks at the careers of Academy Award-winning animators John and Faith Hubley, at their struggle to remain independent in a field that is largely commercial, and at their unique contributions to the development of animation as an art form.

Independent Spirits is about animation: what it is, how it's perceived, what it can be. The film attempts to expand the public perception of animation by moving "beyond pigs and bunnies," as the Hubleys described their art, to arrive at an understanding of animation's artistic and humanistic potential: its potential to deal with serious subjects; its capacity for innovative graphic and structural design; its ability to stimulate both the imagination and the intellect. As animation historian Charles Solomon has written, "the Hubleys did more to make people aware that animation was a legitimate art form than anyone..." With their special blend of intelligence, humor and social commentary, Hubley films were made by animation artists whose ultimate goal was not to have the mouse escape the cat, but rather, as John Hubley said, "to increase awareness, to warn, to humanize, to elevate vision, to suggest goals, to deepen our understanding of ourselves and our relationship to one another." Their non-traditional techniques, a blend of watercolor, wax crayons, multiple exposures and lighting from beneath the camera, give the films a spontaneous appearance, and emphasize the free-form graphic approach that has characterized Hubley style animation. As animation historian John Canemaker has written: "This 'happy accident' graphic style forces audiences to 'fill in the spaces' of what is not seen by using their imaginations."

Independent Spirits is also about the passion, spirit and commitment of independent artists attempting to exist in a culture of compromise. Particularly in the realm of filmmaking, an art form that requires greater financial resources than most others, commissioned work can be an abiding lure, often distracting independents from their passions or even mediating their personal vision. Independent Spirits looks at the issues that independent filmmakers confront every day -- issues that deal with compromise, commitment and the temptation of commerce. The Hubleys' professional choices, even before their partnership began, reflected an intense commitment to political alternatives and a belief in social justice. This film looks at what each of them brought to their unique collaboration: John, an artistic brilliance nurtured at the Disney Studio; Faith, a deep respect for cultural diversity and a rebellious spirit formed in a tough, NYC neighborhood; both, a commitment to progressive politics that influenced their belief that animation could deal with serious subjects and might actually make a difference in the world.

Beginning in the fifties, when they established their independent animation studio, the Hubleys worked to create alternative approaches to artistic self-expression. Films such as Moonbird, Cockaboody and Everybody Rides the Carousel re-defined prior notions of animation in their break from Disney literalism and linearity and in their exploration of animation's potential to communicate serious ideas and confront crucial social issues through the use of innovative graphics and improvisational soundtracks. Their pioneering use of jazz served as an aural equivalent to their alternative graphics and critical content and speaks directly to their commitment to diversity. The Hubleys worked with some of the greatest composers and musicians in the history of jazz, including Benny Carter, Dizzy Gillespie, Ella Fitzgerald and Quincy Jones.

The Hubleys were the first artists to look consistently at the way in which animated film could confront serious social issues. When John and Faith began their collaboration in 1955, they committed to making one independent film a year, in addition to doing work in television commercials, which, as they often stated, they did in order to "put food on the table." Some of the socially progressive themes they dealt with included nuclear arms (The Hole); nationalistic boundaries and barriers that keep people from communicating with one another (The Hat and Voyage to Next); the runaway growth of cities (Urbanissimo); over-population (Eggs) and immigration throughout America's history (People, People, People). Faith's own films have dealt with such subjects as the changing relationships between men and women throughout world history (WOW: Women of the World); the rights of children (Step by Step); the efforts of humankind to leap out of our limited space and view the world through art and music (Sky Dance); the destruction of the Amazon rain forest (Amazonia). Faith's more recent works have represented her ongoing investigation into other cultures and her effort to identify the mythological roots and shared concerns that globally unite us (Cloudland, Tall-Time Tales, and Rainbows of Hawaii are some of her recent titles). Her films are inspired by the myths and legends of other cultures and her explorations convey the importance of recognizing diversity while appreciating the shared concerns that unite us.

In an effort to understand why their collaboration was unique, the film looks at what each of the profiled artists brought to it, as well as at the personal and professional circumstances that influenced their individual contributions:

  • John's artistic brilliance, nurtured at the creatively fertile yet stylistically rigid Disney Studio of the late 1930's.
  • Faith's formative years growing up in Hell's Kitchen and the origins of her awareness of cultural diversity and respect for people of all backgrounds.
  • John's role in the 1941 Disney Studio strike, and the eventual political fallout that participation in the strike had on the careers of many of the artists who did so.
  • John's work at the Air Force First Motion Picture Unit during the war, where animators made stylistically innovative training films that prefigured what would later become known as "UPA style."
  • John's role in the formation of UPA, the studio that directly challenged Disney realism with its emphasis on social commentary and avant-garde graphics. Several of their films, e.g., Brotherhood of Man and Hell-Bent for Election, both made for labor, were among the works that characterized the studio's progressive politics and contributed to its being labeled "the reddest outfit in Hollywood" by the FBI.
  • Disney's role in the animation blacklist; his testimony before HUAC and his naming of names of several strike leaders who had formed UPA as a rival studio.
  • John's blacklisting and forced anonymity working in the uncredited medium of television commercials, many of them now classics, such as the campaign for Maypo cereal ("I want my Maypo!"). It was during this period that he opened Storyboard Productions, where he worked with a front man and was able to continue working in areas that were uncredited, such as television commercials and children's television (Sesame Street and The Electric Company).
  • John's work on the animated version of Finian's Rainbow, a project which was summarily shut down when it was discovered that Hubley was working on it. Accompanying this section are stills of never-before seen artwork that Hubley created for the film.
  • Faith's and her friend Dede Allen's work at Columbia and Republic Studios as assistant editors, and their impressions of the changing attitudes towards women during and after the war.
  • John and Faith's twenty-two year collaboration, during which they made twenty-one independent films, won three Academy Awards (out of seven nominations) and "violated all the rules," with their alternative style of animation and innovative use of sound.
  • Faith's search for recognition and her own voice after John's death, and her continuing unwillingness to compromise; her ongoing struggle to maintain her commitment to art rather than commerce and her impressive record of twenty-one independent solo films made following John's death.

    The difficulty of maintaining an independent vision is complex, and the Hubleys were certainly not without their commercial choices -- their commissioned work covers many areas of popular culture, and they have left their mark on television advertising, children's television and feature films -- but always, they returned to what they had promised each other in their marriage vows, i.e., "to make at least one independent film a year," a promise that Faith Hubley has maintained even after her husband's death in 1977. As Faith has said in one of her on-camera interviews in our film, "The ability to make what you want to make is so fundamental...I keep thinking of the parallel of a painter. What would happen if a painter had to do everything by commission?...We would lose art."

    Director and Producer Bios

    SYBIL DELGAUDIO (Director) directed the four-part series, Animated Women, produced for ITVS in 1995. The series won recognition at many festivals and museums, and was honored with an Emmy Award and a CINE Golden Eagle. The series has aired on many PBS affiliates and on the BBC as well. DelGaudio teaches film studies and production at Hofstra University, where she is professor and chair of the Department of Audio/Video/Film. She is a film historian whose reviews and articles are published widely, and she is a frequent speaker and panel moderator on topics relating to film theory and animation.

    PATTY WINEAPPLE (Producer) is a CLIO Award-winner who has been working in film and television production since 1967. Currently, she is Vice-President and Group Executive Producer at Grey Worldwide, New York, where she specializes in commercials that make use of animation. In 1980, she produced SPFX-1138, a short film directed by Bob Balaban. In 1982, she produced Broadway, My Street, a television special starring Jerry Ohrbach and Florence Henderson. She is also the series producer for Animated Women.

  • Independent Spirits website at PBS.org

    This page contains information about the animation program from the 2001 festival.
    For information on this year's festival, follow the links below.

    Animation Program 2001 | Animation Program Index
    High Falls Film Fest Official Site | Animatus Main Page